View Other Items in this Archive | View All Archives | Printable Version

Surprise Police Department
Phone: 623-222-4000
Fax: 623-222-4008

For Immediate Release

Police seek public assistance to locate woman and child

Surprise, AZ (July 13, 2021) The Surprise Police Department is seeking public assistance in locating Fallon Costello, a 27 year old white female and her daughter, 2 year old Paytan Costello. Costello and her daughter were last seen at their residence in the area of 16000 W. Banff Lane during an investigation by the Department of Child Safety (DCS). Costello and her daughter, left the residence unbeknownst to DCS Investigators through a bedroom window. Fallon Costello was last seen wearing a pink top and black pants. Payton was last seen wearing a purple nightgown.

Fallon and Payton Costello were then observed at 1218 pm, in the area of Reems and Greenway Road, entering into a newer model white Dodge Caravan with a sticker in the front passenger window. The license plate number is unknown at this time. (Actual vehicle pictured below)

Anyone with any information regarding the location of Fallon and Paytan Costello is asked to contact the Surprise Police at (623) 222.4000, or 623.222.TIPS (8477), or email

When contacting the police, reference incident number #210702647.

City of Surprise Police Department
14250 W. Statler Plaza, Surprise, AZ 85374 | Phone: 623-222-4000